Microblog Mondays: Lifeboats

In the last couple of weeks E. has suddenly developed an intense interest in the Titanic, which means we now have several books about said ship out from the library, including the exact book I used to own when I was a child with an intense interest in the Titanic.

E. is aware, of course, that the story of the Titanic is a tragic one, a cautionary tale of needless loss of life, but he approaches the subject largely on technical grounds. He is interested in the hows and whys of the sinking and (especially) the discovery and exploration of the wreck. When I was a child I was most interested in the exploration of the wreck as well (I even had a second book by Titanic discoverer Robert Ballard, about the wreck of the Bismarck).

I am really having a hard time with the story the second time around.

As an adult, I can’t escape the horror of the human side to the sinking. I’m finding it difficult to read aloud to E. the sections which detail the children who perished, or the reports from survivors of the haunting cries of the doomed passengers as they struggled to survive in the icy waters, or (especially) the myriad mistakes which led to the tragedy (first and foremost the fact that there weren’t enough lifeboats on board). He doesn’t seem to be bothered by any of it, but I am.

I’ve tried to mostly stop thinking about the children, because I find it too upsetting, so instead my mind keeps coming back to Ida Straus, who was offered a place in one of the lifeboats, but chose instead to stay on board the Titanic with her husband, saying, “We have lived together for many years. Where you go, I go.”

I don’t think I could do that.

I love Q. very much and couldn’t imagine a life without him. But I think if I were offered the chance to live, I would take it.

Maybe my reaction is a result of the phase of life that I’m currently in. Obviously there are E. and P. to think about, and (in this imagined scenario), if they were in a lifeboat, I would get in that boat to be with them in a heartbeat. Maybe I would feel differently if I were (like Ida was), in my sixties, with my children grown, having been married to Q. for four decades rather than one.

I don’t think so, though.

Q.’s mother was widowed fourteen years ago, when she was in her early fifties. I’ve watched her build a life that in no way resembles the life that she was expecting to have, but it is still a life of great joy, a life of adventure, a meaningful life.

Maybe Ida would have felt differently had she lived in the twenty-first century and had all the opportunities available to women that we enjoy.

Or maybe she loved her husband more than I love Q.

It’s something I think about.

Would you get in the lifeboat?

This post is part of #MicroblogMondays. To read the inaugural post and find out how you can participate, click here.



Filed under E.- the seventh year, Microblog Mondays

4 responses to “Microblog Mondays: Lifeboats

  1. I think it is not that simple, and it’s not at all simple the way you’ve framed the choice. There were hundreds of people who weren’t going to make it onto lifeboats. The person next to her might have been a young mother, a child, a father watching his family board. Maybe it was a choice exclusively about love, but I doubt it. Also, the denial on board the Titanic was powerful. She may have believed deeply that they would be rescued in time.
    I don’t think I could leave Pea behind. I hope I’m never on board a sinking ship with such terrible safety features.

  2. It is a tough question. I could certainly imagine a life without my husband – I think if you can’t imagine that, then you have no imagination or are willingly refusing to try. But, after 30+ years together, I would hate the thought of leaving him alone, to go through that alone.

  3. I agree with the others. How could anyone really know? When you first talked about not wanting to hear this story again, it made me think of my Dad. When Saving Private Ryan, JFK, and Schindler’s List came out, he refused to see all of them.. I remember him telling me: “I lived through all of it. Who wants to live through it again?”.

  4. Turia

    Yes, I agree it’s not a simple question, and probably not a thought I should have tried to squeeze into a Microblog Mondays post! It is just something I have been mulling over while reading endless descriptions of flooding “watertight” compartments and ignored iceberg warnings. There must have been many women who also had to make that choice (including eight who were on their honeymoon- six of them lost their husbands), and, of course, many women who had no choice to make because the lifeboats were gone by the time they reached the deck.

    @labmonkey- you might be right about the denial aspect. According to one of the books it was lifeboat 8 where she refused a place and that was one of the earlier ones to be launched.

    @Mali- I think it’s not that I can’t imagine a life without Q., it’s more that I’m incapable of imagining what that life would look like (if that makes sense- I can imagine living without him but not how that living would be).

    Ideally I would like to die at or around the same time as Q., just preferably not until we’re in our eighties or nineties!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s